New shoes & stargazing
Blog Post 3
New shoes is a heartwarming and informative text that takes the reader on a whirlwind adventure. Francis, the main character of the story, a shoe maker, needs to collect tiger grass to make a pair of shoes for a special customer. Francis, along side Rhoda a colorful bird, head into the South American forest to collect their supplies. Along the way they encounter amazing animals, tricky situations, and learn a lot about themselves too. They find out their friend Nigel is in trouble and it is up to them to save him. Francis uses creativity and art to create the perfect "pair of shoes" or a transportation device for his special client, the famous Miss Manatee. This book, designed as a graphic novel, includes amazing illustrations and dialogue between the characters that bring them to life. The text includes many authentic native animals, the native language, and a genuine portrayal of the environment. The story takes place in Guyana. The author herself, Sara Varon, has traveled there many times and include images of the village in the back of the book to allow the reader to see the authenticity and feel truly apart of the story.
Stargazing, is also a graphic novel that follows two unlikely friends on their heartwarming story and the heavy life events they must overcome together. Christine and Moon form a strong bond over their culture, shared interests, and their determination to preform together at the school talent show. Moon is a free spirited young girl who has had a tough life. Moon claims she sees messages and people in the stars. This bring comfort to her. Christine, polar opposite, finds Moon refreshing and interesting. After an altercation at their classmates birthday party Moon and Christine get into a fight. Those bad feelings go away when Moon is diagnosed with a brain tumor. Christine knows she must step up and be the friend Moon needs so desperately. After using the talent show to raise money for Moons medical bills the two are better friends then ever. This story written by Jen Wang incorporates much of her childhood and is based off her experience having a brain tumor as a young child. The book contains authentic Chinese meals, the language, and names of the Chinese culture. The illustrations are creative and reflect the moods represented throughout the story.
Texts presented as graphic novels offer so much to the reader and as a teacher. Graphic novels offer a new perspective on reading for students who might struggle to get through a lengthy chapter book. The text features alone in graphic novels are part of the reading experience and take time to comprehend as the reader. These features add so much to the story and bring It to life right before the readers eyes. The sound "effects", facial expressions, and thought bubbles add a whole other level to the text. I loved reading these books and find them as great opportunities to get students excited about reading and a way to teach about cultures in an authentic way.
These texts have similar themes that can work together to teach about critical issues that students might experience. Both books show pairs of unlikely friends that overcome hard times together and grow together. In New Shoes, Francis and Rhoda who started as village acquaintances, go into unfamiliar territory surrounded by unfamiliar animals and become best pals. They each teach one another about patience, bravery, and how they can count on each other. In Stargazing, Christine is apprehensive about Moon at first but after getting to know each other they become so close and overcome so much together. These stories can teach students so much about not judging a book by its cover when It comes to creating friendships. We can never assume things about people and the most unlikely people can surprise us. It is crucial to open your students eyes to making connections and expanding their community with people they might not have been open to before.
Using this critical issue as the teaching point, being open minded as the goal, and these texts as the foundation of the lesson there are many ways to implement this into the classroom. After reading the texts with the class we will take time to reflect. Reflect on the characters, what they go through together, and the friendships that form in the most unlikely of circumstances. After taking a deep dive into the characters and what the students admire about them, what reminds them of themselves, and which character they might want to know more about to talk to in person, the class can write a letter to the characters. In these letters they can ask them questions, talk about how far they have come with the friends they have made in the texts, and what they have learned from their story. After writing their letters we can take time to take a step back and look at our roles in our community and the friends we are and strive to be. As mentioned in Chapter 7 from Reading to Make a Difference, it's so important to have these conversations with your students and encourage making these connections.
Book
Characters
New Shoes
Rhoda, Francis, Nigel
Stargazing
Moon, Christine
Description
Francis a Shoe Maker goes on an adventure along side his pal Rhoda to get the supplies to make his famous clients shoes. Along the way these two learn much about themselves and each other.
Moon and Christine couldn't be more different but after getting to know each other these unlikely friends create a long lasting bond and overcome hardships together
Character Changes
Francis learns about taking risks and getting out of his comfort zone by leaving his small village. Nigel learns about conservation and producing his own tiger grass.
Christine learns to not jump to conclusions about people after Moon surprises her by being an awesome friend. Christine tries new things thanks to Moon. Moon fights a brain tumor thanks to the support of Christine
Compare/ Contrast
These two stories show the power of unlikely friends and the unlimited possibilities when you give someone a chance. After being proved wrong about someone they once judged, they learn valuable lessons about identity and friendship.
Message
A overarching message is to get to know someone before making assumptions. Take time to make your own friendships and never judge a book by its cover. Show kindness to everyone and never doubt yourself or the people around you.
Cultural authenticity
Both texts portray the cultures authentically in different ways. In Stargazing, the author Jen Wang brings in her experiences and represents her culture through authentic foods, names, and language. In New Shoes the author Sara Varon who has traveled to Guyana several times includes pictures and conducted research to incorporate authentic animals, environment, and language into the text.
Stargazing: A Deeper Look
By choosing one page in a graphic novel we can learn a lot about the characters and their emotions. This spread shows us a lot about Christine and how she is still apprehensive in the beginning of the book. Moon has started showing her how to get out of her comfort zone but when her father sees her dancing she get embarrassed and nervous. We know all of this just through the facial expressions and details included on the page.
Using this in our classroom;
1. Use this page to conduct a read aloud and take your time looking at every word, detail, and movement conducted by each character.
2. Create to organize the students thoughts and break down each part of the pages.
3. Post a sticky note on the first part of the page as we see Christine loosen up and dance to the music. Identify her mood and actions
4. Identify her reaction and facial expression when her dad walks in. Talk about how Moon reacts.
5. Discuss how the page ends and make predictions for what might happen next with Christine, Moon, and her dad.
Author information
Resources
Laminak, L. L. & Kelly, K. (2019). Reading to Make a Difference: Using literature to help students speak freely, think deeply, and take action. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann
Varon, S (2018). New Shoes. First Second Publishing.
Wang, J (2019). Stargazing. First Second Publishing.